Nightmare Pain
Spell Continuous

Nightmare Pain

  • Archetype:
  • Signature move

  • View:
  • 8109




During your Main Phase: You can destroy 1 DARK monster in your hand or face-up field, and if you do, add 1 "Yubel", or 1 card that mentions it, from your Deck to your hand, except "Nightmare Pain". You can only use this effect of "Nightmare Pain" once per turn. While you control a "Yubel" monster, your opponent's monsters that can attack must attack "Yubel" monsters. Your opponent takes any battle damage you would have taken from battles involving your "Yubel" monsters.




 
 
AI Power Analysis
Searcher/TutorConfidence: MediumEvaluated Oct 9, 2026
52± 8/ 100
Power Score
Intrinsic 47
Deck 55

Nightmare Pain — Power Evaluation

Final Score: 52 ± 8 · Confidence: Medium

  • Intrinsic: 47 · Deck: 55 · Meta: provisional
  • Primary role: Searcher/Tutor · Secondary: Floodgate/Control

Why it scores here

Nightmare Pain is a Yubel-engine searcher: each Main Phase (once per turn) it trades a DARK monster for one Yubel or Yubel-mentioning card, so its value is card-for-card and depends on a Yubel shell. Its attack redirect and battle-damage redirect only work while you control a Yubel monster, which keeps interaction modest. The 400 decks and 100% partner overlap with Yubel confirm it is a reliable staple in that shell, not that it is intrinsically powerful. Its 100 possible ATK or stat values earn nothing, and the combo data shows no starter, searched, material or payoff role for it.

Axis scores

Axis Score Evidence
Accessibility 60 Placed face-up as a Continuous Spell and active each Main Phase, present in all 400 sampled decks with an average of 1.67 copies (deck data; the search itself needs a DARK monster in hand or on field) (observed).
Combo & Conversion 45 Searches one Yubel-mention card per turn, but none of its 16 combo appearances tag it as starter, searched, payoff or end-board, and the example boards average a power index of 42.2 (combo data) (observed).
Resource Economy 40 Destroying one DARK monster to add one card is a 1-for-1 exchange; the example boards show netCardAdvantage of 0 to 4 with no recorded refuel (combo data; card text) (verified).
Effect & Interaction 40 No negation or removal of opponent cards; the forced attack onto Yubel monsters and the battle-damage redirect apply only while you control a Yubel monster (card text) (verified).
Material Utility 0 A Spell Card can never be used as Link, Synchro, Xyz or Fusion material, so this axis is zero (card text) (verified).
Resilience & Flexibility 40 The Continuous Spell stays on field until it is destroyed, and its effect is once per turn and depends on Yubel being present (card text; vulnerability to Spell/Trap removal is inferred) (inferred).
Deck-Building Efficiency 55 Runs at 1 to 3 copies in Yubel shells with no garnet or lock, but it is only worth a slot when the Yubel engine is already included (deck data; card text) (observed).

Calculation

Weight profile: 0.7 Searcher/Tutor + 0.3 Floodgate/Control blend. Intrinsic ≈ 47, Deck ≈ 55, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: none. Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck

Strengths

  • Repeatable once-per-turn search for the Yubel engine (card text)
  • Present in all 400 sampled decks, almost all of them Yubel shells (deck data)
  • Forces opponent attacks onto Yubel monsters and redirects battle damage while a Yubel is controlled (card text)

Weaknesses

  • Card-for-card search, so no net card advantage on its own (card text; netCardAdvantage 0 in examples)
  • Requires a DARK monster in hand or on field to be destroyed (card text)
  • Effects depend on controlling a Yubel monster, so it is weak outside that shell (card text)
  • Combo data does not tag it as starter, searched, material or payoff in any of 16 appearances (combo data)

Counters / choke points

  • Removal of the face-up Continuous Spell ends its ongoing redirect and search access (inferred from card type)
  • Destroying or removing the Yubel monsters that enable the redirect stops the forced-attack effect (inferred from card text)

Best use

Yubel engine searcher with an attack-forcing and damage-redirect add-on. Decks: Yubel, Unchained, Fiendsmith.

Evidence & gaps

  • Verified: Once-per-turn Main Phase search of a Yubel or Yubel-mentioning card by destroying a DARK monster (card text); Attack-forcing and battle-damage redirect while a Yubel monster is controlled (card text); Spell Card, so it can never be material (card text); Present in 400 of 400 sampled decks (deck data)
  • Observed: Appears in 16 of 16 sampled combos with no tagged role (combo data); Average power index of boards containing it is 42.2 (combo data); Top partners Spirit of Yubel (100%) and Yubel (99.8%) (deck data); Copies per deck average 1.67, with 3 as the maximum (deck data)
  • Inferred: Vulnerable to Spell/Trap removal while face-up; Its power depends on the Yubel engine being present
  • Data gaps: No banlist token, so 3 copies are assumed (unlimited) No role tags in combo data, so the starter/searcher/payoff roles rest on text and deck usage No metagame sample, so meta power is null Only one guide mentions the card, and it is a community write-up











https://metaduelist.com/
Top